Thank you. I was going to ask for this as it makes a big difference. Also the original photoshop made the red lollipop look too fat and cartoony which was swaying my judgement.
I think #3 looks more formal and #5 looks more playful. Maybe in person they'll be almost no difference. I agree with the voters that the red lollipop looks more special than just the tip.
That'd be great for us Christmas shoppers!