I currently have about 100 pens and around 220 inks in my collection.
I think it was me who introduced Lindsey to this rabbit hole, but she had the strength of character to get out before it was too late!
JAFO wrote: ↑Sun May 12, 2024 8:49 am I would have thought the two everyman brands of pens, that represent proto luxury would be Parker and Papermate. Maybe Shaeffer and Waterman also.
I think if I had a pen company, I would be more than happy for it to be compared to Parker in particular as entry level luxury.
You're about 30-40 years out of date, Dave. These four companies are a shadow of their former selves, and their modern pens are distinctly average at best. Parker, in particular, are awful nowadays. Of course, their vintage pens still work and there is an active market in them. The Parker 51, in particular, is an absolute classic pen that is still beautiful to use.
Montblanc are a bit like the Rolex of the pen world. They are well known and are the typical aspiration for someone wanted a luxurious, top-of-the-range fountain pen. Like Rolex, their product is, indeed, very good, but also like Rolex, there are other companies out there with products which are as good, if not better, for a similar price.
In terms of which pen manufacturer is the equivalent of CW in the fountain pen world, it is hard to say. If you want something designed and made in the UK (other than the nibs which are probably German - a la Swiss in the watch world), I would suggest a company called Onoto. This was, historically, a famous UK/Scottish brand before World War II. Nowadays, it has been resurrected and is based just outside Norwich, and makes very high quality pens, with distinctive designs, at reasonable prices.
Other non-UK pen companies offer high quality products for generally lower prices than Montblanc include:
Pilot (especially the Custom 823)
Sailor (especially the Pro Gear Large)
Pelikan (especially the Souveran range)
Faber-Castell (their steel nibs are excellent and not at all expensive)
Lamy (especially the 2000 and their other models with gold nibs)
TWSBI (especially good at the cheaper end)
Just stay away from ballpoints altogether. And only use rollerballs in an absolute emergency!
Hope that helps.