I haven't really been following this thread but here are a couple of things I thought I might lob to see where they land...
Have folks with new watches fully wound the watch? With most automatics you can sense when the watch is wound because of the very slight occasional click when you've reached maximum. Maybe about 30-40 winds from scratch. A new watch that is just put on the wrist won't be fully wound and the rate will vary quite a bit. When fully wound, an automatic will regain the amount of winding it loses overnight pretty quickly next morning.
A second thing to check is whether you are consistent with how the watch rests overnight. Watchmakers refer to 6 positions: dial up, dial down, crown up, crown down, crown left (as it faces you) and crown right. Because of the deployant most will probably be leaving the watch crown up overnight. Position will typically only make a few seconds difference per day but it might be another source of variation.
If your watch spends much the same time off the wrist overnight and is worn throughout the day then you can track the rate more accurately. When I've done this I have tracked the time first thing each mornning before the watch has been worn much.
Mine was pretty constant around +8 seconds crown up or dial up for about a week. It dropped to +6 once or twice but it was actually very steady. I haven't bothered checking it lately.
